Samsung has started sending units of its futuristic Galaxy Fold to the tech press, and judging by recent reports, it's likely they're not thinking it was such a good idea right now. Several media outlets have reported screen problems with their test devices after just one day of use. What's going on with the first foldable phone on the market?
Are the Galaxy Fold failing?
This week, Samsung finally began granting the press access to its Galaxy Fold. In Spain, for example, our colleagues at Movilzona traveled to London to get their hands on it and share their impressions of the foldable phone , while in the US, the Korean company has gone a step further: they have started lending units to specialized media outlets for testing and review.
Everything up to now seemed to be going normally and in fact the first opinions about the phone (after hours of use) were quite favorable: few doubt how incredible its design is and the possibilities that such a concept can offer in the world of telephony. However, there have been some problems along the way. Let's analyze them one by one.
Case 1: the speck of dust?
The well-known American website The Verge published an article a few minutes ago stating that its Galaxy Fold unit has broken. Literally. The article describes , and shows with photos, that its phone has a small bump at the bottom of the screen's fold, noticeable enough to distort the panel and even feel it with a finger. In fact, initially it was just a small protrusion, but over time (and with repeated opening and closing, of course), it has ended up damaging the screen, causing a vertical and horizontal green line to appear, originating from the bump.
My Samsung Galaxy Fold screen broke after just a day https://t.co/68YwG1034i pic.twitter.com/LgnLaZ1Gx0
— The Verge (@verge) April 17, 2019
The person in charge of analyzing the device indicates that he has used the smartphone normally and is trying to find some explanation by looking at the places where he has kept the phone: his pocket or the stand (made of a clay-like material) he uses to prop up phones for taking photos. The writer believes that a tiny particle (of dust or clay) may have gotten in through the phone's most vulnerable point, the gap that forms when it is folded, causing this damage.
Case 2: The screen protector you should NOT remove
When you buy a phone, it always comes with an extra screen protector to protect it from the hustle and bustle of factory tampering. This layer is usually removed -although there are people who leave it- since the phones are already sufficiently protected with technologies such as Gorilla Glass.
The Galaxy Fold, however, doesn't have Gorilla Glass or any other protective technology—that's what happens with such a new concept and a flexible screen. Therefore, this phone also comes with a flexible polymer over the panel that acts as a screen protector and should never be removed , something Mark Gurman and Marques Brownlee didn't know.
Both the journalist and the YouTuber removed the protective layer and ended up damaging their phones, albeit under very different circumstances. Gurman claims he removed it because the corner seemed "accessible" and it took him a few hours to see the consequences.
The phone comes with this protective layer/film. Samsung says you are not supposed to remove it. I removed it, not knowing you're not supposed to (consumers won't know either). It appeared removable in the left corner, so I took it off. I believe this contributed to the problem. pic.twitter.com/fU646D2zpY
— Mark Gurman (@markgurman) April 17, 2019
Removing the layer left the screen much more vulnerable , causing what appears to be a crack in the central crease.
There is a very small tear at the top part of the hinge and after I poked at it, the screen got worse. I thought perhaps it was another removable layer. Tear may have been caused by removing it. But @stevekovach @backlon having similar issues without having removed the film. pic.twitter.com/9WCPmEMpB1
— Mark Gurman (@markgurman) April 17, 2019
This resulted in a 50% image loss on the panel and has been growing like a stain until it covers almost the entire screen.
The screen on my Galaxy Fold review unit is completely broken and unusable just two days in. Hard to know if this is widespread or not. pic.twitter.com/G0OHj3DQHw
— Mark Gurman (@markgurman) April 17, 2019
It has gotten progressively worse. Here's the latest, photo taken now. One photo is from last night. Another photo is earlier this morning. pic.twitter.com/qzmlM0a3pL
— Mark Gurman (@markgurman) April 17, 2019
As for Marques Brownlee , the YouTuber was also unaware that this layer shouldn't be removed and began peeling it off from the bottom center. Apparently, the manipulation itself while doing so ended up damaging the screen, which turned off completely and never worked again.
PSA: There's a layer that appears to be a screen protector on the Galaxy Fold's display. It's NOT a screen protector. Do NOT remove it.
I got this far peeling it off before the display spazzed and blacked out. Started over with a replacement. pic.twitter.com/ZhEG2Bqulr
— Marques Brownlee (@MKBHD) April 17, 2019
Case 3: Broken from use?
So far we have listed cases in which there seems to be an external agent that ends up taking the life of the phone due to the apparent fragility of its screen. This third incident, however, does not feature killer specks or don't-remove protectors: it appears to be simply for use.
After one day of use… pic.twitter.com/VjDlJI45C9
— Steve Kovach (@stevekovach) April 17, 2019
As you can see in the image shared by Steve Kobach—who doesn't mention whether or not he removed the protective layer—his phone shows a black line down the center, right where it folds, and half of the screen flickers. This black line could be a physical crack in the panel, causing the central pixels to go dark, leading us to believe that the panel fractured precisely at the bending point—if you look closely, it's the same spot as in Gurman's case. Samsung previously released a video showing its Galaxy Fold phones opening and closing repeatedly to reassure users, so what could have happened?
https://youtu.be/McdgS3Popjk
What conclusion do we draw from all this?
Over the years, we've come across many phones that included a fixed screen protector designed to shield the panel from external damage. These are no longer as common thanks to advancements in technologies like Gorilla Glass, but they still demonstrate the fragility that screens can have. The Galaxy Fold, by its very nature, was no exception, but user ignorance has led to the situations we've described in some cases.
Marques Brownlee himself criticizes the fact that the Galaxy Fold box does not state at any point that the screen protector should not be removed, something that should be emphasized quite clearly, and is an important factor to consider in this whole story.
* Update : As we can see in the tweet from @askdes on Twitter, the Galaxy Fold box DOES indicate that the phone has a protective layer that should NOT be removed.
Dear future #GalaxyFold owners, I know I always say “No one ever read the instructions”… PLEASE READ THIS ONE!!!
(This is the wrap over the screen of the Galaxy Fold) pic.twitter.com/LuQPRfDZIE
— Des (@askdes) April 17, 2019
The case of the intruding "particle" is more worrying. It raises the possibility of an Achilles' heel in the phone, a gap through which dirt or other particles can easily seep , triggering the same disaster. As for case 3, it only serves to revive the fear many had when we first saw the concept: "How will the screen hold up over time?"
It's worth remembering something else (and very important in this whole story): these phones are still test units , not final versions, and will (we hope) be very different from what will reach the market - if Samsung has gotten to where it is, among other things, it's because it knows how to make devices with good build quality every time.
The Koreans have a tough task ahead of them in the coming days. Do not worry, if there are news, we will send it to you here.
[ Note : The cover image has been intentionally modified to better illustrate this article.]
Table of Contents